For this week’s Justice Notes, I’m sharing an essay by Jeff Grant, founder of the White Collar Support Group, of which I’ve been a member for several years.
Jeff writes about his reinstatement to the New York Bar following his federal conviction and incarceration, and the meaning of a second chance. He also introduces the Federal Expungement Initiative and its inaugural Federal Expungement & Pardon Conference, scheduled for March 20, 2027.
For those of us who have experienced the consequences of a criminal conviction, his central question is particularly relevant: At what point does accountability become perpetual punishment?
When Is a Second Chance Really a Second Chance? My Personal Journey
Why the White Collar Support Group and the Federal Expungement Initiative are Hosting the Inaugural Federal Expungement & Pardon Conference on March 20, 2027
By Jeff Grant, Esq.
On May 5, 2021, something extraordinary happened in my life.
After nearly two decades of disbarment, following my conviction and imprisonment for a federal white collar crime, I was reinstated to the New York Bar.
I was a lawyer again.
There have been many defining moments in my life: my arrest, my imprisonment, the day I got sober, and the day I became an ordained minister. But my reinstatement was something different. It was a recognition that, notwithstanding the worst things I had done, I was not forever defined by them.
It was more powerful to me — emotionally, spiritually, psychologically and financially — than receiving a presidential pardon could ever have been.
And perhaps most importantly, it meant something profound to my children.
Their dad was back.
They could introduce me to their friends as their father, the lawyer. Not their father who used to be a lawyer. Not their father who had gone to prison.
Just their dad. The lawyer.
As a father, I cannot adequately describe what that meant to me. It was a seminal moment for my family, and it fundamentally shaped my understanding of what a real second chance can mean (even, as I admit, that there might be a lot of transference going on and it might be my shame that has clouded my memory of much of this. Perhaps my family cared far less about my law reinstatement than I did? Or, at least had their own emotions about it that I should not misappropriate here).
Why I Chose Not to Seek a Presidential Pardon
Over the years, people have asked whether I would apply for a presidential pardon. My answer has been no.
Not because I don’t believe in pardons. Quite the opposite. Presidential clemency can provide extraordinary relief to deserving people. But I had already regained my profession, my livelihood, my identity and, in important ways, my dignity. A pardon would not have added anything comparable to my own life.
I also knew how fortunate I was.
Countless lawyers, doctors, accountants, businesspeople and other professionals have lost licenses, careers and opportunities because of criminal convictions. Many have served their sentences, made restitution, accepted responsibility and rebuilt their lives. Yet the doors that opened for me remain firmly closed to them.
And beyond the professional community are millions of other Americans whose convictions continue to follow them long after their formal punishment has ended.
Through the White Collar Support Group, which I co-founded in 2016, I have come to know many of these people. Some are still navigating the criminal justice system. Others have been home for years, even decades, working to rebuild their families, careers and self-respect.
We call this the white collar life sentence — the punishment that continues long after the sentence imposed by a judge has ended.
This raises a question that has become central to my life and ministry:
At what point does accountability become perpetual punishment?
Why Pardons Are Not Enough
Presidential pardons are an important constitutional remedy, but they depend upon the discretion of a single person, the President of the United States. Even when granted, a pardon does not erase the underlying conviction from a person’s criminal record.
There are already many people seeking clemency, and countless others who might apply if they believed there were a realistic opportunity for relief.
No matter how generously a President exercised the pardon power, it could only scratch the surface.
So I began asking a different question:
Why shouldn’t people who have served their federal sentences, made amends and demonstrated rehabilitation have a meaningful opportunity to petition for expungement of their criminal records?
That question became the foundation of the Federal Expungement Initiative.
A Vision for Federal Expungement
I have been privileged to work alongside some extraordinary scholars and advocates in developing this initiative.
Together with Professors Rachel Barkow of NYU School of Law, Douglas Berman of The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law, and Mark Osler of the University of St. Thomas School of Law, we co-founded the Federal Expungement Initiative. Todd Haugh of Indiana University’s Kelley School of Business has joined us, bringing his considerable expertise in white collar crime and ethics. Many more advisors, advocates and collaborators have joined us, as well.
Each of these colleagues brings remarkable scholarship and experience in criminal justice, sentencing, clemency and reform. I bring my own lived experience, legal career, ministry, and the voices of the many people who have entrusted me with their stories through the White Collar Support Group.
Together, we envision something ambitious but achievable: federal legislation establishing a meaningful process for expungement of eligible criminal convictions.
Under such legislation, people who have completed their sentences and met carefully established criteria — including rehabilitation, accountability and other safeguards determined by Congress — would have the opportunity to petition a federal court for expungement.
This is hardly a radical concept. Many states already provide some form of expungement, record sealing or Clean Slate relief. Yet there is no comparable, broadly available process for most federal convictions.
Our guiding principle is simple:
People who enter the federal criminal justice system should, under appropriate circumstances, have an opportunity to exit it.
Not automatically. Not without accountability. But with a meaningful opportunity to earn a second chance.
Why We’re Gathering on March 20, 2027
On Saturday, March 20, 2027, at 9 a.m. Eastern Time, the White Collar Support Group and the Federal Expungement Initiative will host our inaugural Federal Expungement & Pardon Conference, online and open to a national audience.
For me, this is much more than another conference. It represents an important step in what has become one of the central passions of my life and ministry.
We are bringing together leading legal scholars, attorneys, advocates, criminal justice reform organizations, policymakers and people with lived experience to examine presidential clemency, federal expungement, and the possibilities for meaningful legislative reform.
We intend to build a broad, bipartisan coalition. We know there will be difficult questions about eligibility, public safety, victims’ rights and the proper standards for relief. Those are conversations worth having.
Our goal is not simply to hold a conference. Our goal is to help build a movement.
And in the months leading up to March 20, I intend to write, speak, participate in podcasts and interviews, and help bring these issues into a larger national conversation.
For Me, This Is Personal
My faith teaches me about forgiveness, grace and redemption. My legal training teaches me about accountability, proportionality and the rule of law. My own life journey has taught me that these principles need not conflict.
I believe people must be held accountable for the harm they cause. I also believe they can change, make amends and earn the opportunity to move forward.
When I was reinstated to the New York Bar, people who had examined my life and character determined that I deserved another chance. That restoration changed my life and my family’s life.
I want others to have that same possibility.
For some, it may mean regaining a professional license. For others, finding employment, securing housing or finally escaping the stigma of a conviction from long ago. For still others, it may mean something much more personal: being able to look their children in the eyes and know that they have truly been given another chance.
The White Collar Support Group has become one of the great ministries of my life. The Federal Expungement Initiative is a natural extension of that calling.
I believe redemption must mean more than simply telling people they are forgiven.
At some point, it must also mean opening doors.
I invite attorneys, academics, policymakers, nonprofit leaders, people impacted by the criminal justice system, their families, and anyone who believes in the possibility of redemption to join us on March 20, 2027.
Jeff Grant, Esq., is an attorney, faith leader, and co-founder of the White Collar Support Group and the Federal Expungement Initiative. He is the founder of GrantLaw, PLLC, and has dedicated his life to supporting people and families navigating the white collar criminal justice system and its aftermath.
Originally published by Jeff Grant on Medium. Reprinted with permission.
Justice Notes is an ongoing series examining incarceration, rehabilitation, storytelling, institutional power, and the lives that exist behind prison walls.
If this piece resonated with you, consider sharing it or leaving a comment. To support this work and help spread awareness about justice reform for white-collar defendants, subscribe to White-Collar Journal and stay connected. John DiMenna is a member of the White Collar Support Group.
To leave a comment, Substack may ask you to verify your email address (a one-time step to prevent spam). You don’t need to subscribe or create an account. Just check your inbox for a one-time link.

