Another selection from A Different Kind of Hell, forthcoming in a second edition from Moonstone Press.
I wrote this while lying in my bunk in prison, recalling the day of my sentencing hearing. The words came almost in a trance, an uninterrupted recollection of the drive to the courthouse, the arrival, and the hearing itself. I’ve left it substantially as I wrote it then, hoping to capture something of the experience as I lived it.
RECKONING DAY
The Drive
On the drive there I passed the building and its imposing columns that told me something serious and ominous goes on there and I carried that entering the dark garage and its low ceiling while driving up level after level to find a parking spot and why shouldn’t there be one so early in the morning and where the hell was everyone or were they already in there in that imposing government building and its false promise from its long landscaped walkway and park like grounds in front that’s not a park or even close to a park but a courthouse disguised as a park but it can’t fool a defendant who knows it’s a court house and all the spots in the garage are taken because everybody’s already in there waiting in ambush for me and then I found a spot on the last level but needed three passes to get in with barely enough room to fit without hitting the cars next to me and the long walk down those ramps almost tripping on the cracked concrete while looking for others entering the garage but no one I knew which just confirmed again that they were already there waiting for me and have been waiting for me for years and maybe even sitting there for years while the slow deliberate punishment they planned for me evolved for so long sometimes I thought they’d forgotten about me but they hadn’t forgotten about me and they will never have forgotten about me.
The Arrival
The court is set up like a theatre or a church service because the audience is the story of the drama and in fact is the drama and I felt it entering the lobby greeted by uniforms and the steel and glass barriers and everyone removing everything from their pockets and lines forming and those who look used to it and those who stumble with their phones and their briefcases and the women with their purses who struggle to gather what they need and then it was my turn to wait to walk through the monitor until the guard waved me on as if I could be anyone and I could be anywhere with no recognition from him that I was a criminal or that we were in a courthouse and it could even be a movie theatre or mall entrance and no urgency in his routine, giving me some kind of false hope that nothing bad is ahead as he waved me through while I anticipated the rings or the bells or some other alarm but it didn’t go off and I picked up my things, my shoes my belt my glasses and it doesn’t matter who I’m with because no one was talking and I didn’t even see anyone else because I was alone and I knew that they didn’t want to be with me any more than I wanted to be there with them and even in the elevator crowded and silent with others I didn’t know confirming that they were actually in there waiting for me and I finally arrived in the court room into a center hall with pews on each side already filled with people I didn’t dare look at because I knew who they were and like a wedding with friends on one side and enemies on the other and it didn’t matter who was friend and who was foe because I didn’t want to look at either one since both evoke a horror of sorts but I felt everyone on both sides turning and staring and judging but I just kept walking to the table on the left where my lawyer was sitting looking at papers and seeming an island of sanctuary until he greeted me in an awkward move to stand up but only got half way there and I could see that he was as scared as I was but was trying to fake the greeting so much so I realized he’d been sugar coating everything to me and I wanted to fire him on the spot and over his shoulder was the other table where the prosecutor and his team loitered around their table with smiles and what seemed like normal conversation going on and they looked like the good guys and in fact are the good guys and I’d’ve given anything to be at their table to plead with them one more final time to convince them that I’m not a bad person that I just need five more minutes of their time to please please change their minds because I don’t think I can do this and just when I almost did it the bailiff called all to stand and it was a blur as the sound of everyone rising and the judge emerging from a high door with his robes flowing almost like a priest settling in a flash in his high backed chair above everyone in the room on an altar of sorts and in almost one movement of entering and seating and hitting the gavel that sounded almost like a cannon at least to me.
The Hearing
My lawyer said there would be only five speakers against me which sounded like a lot to me and then he said after a while that there would be seven speakers but tried to reassure me that seven was okay and that we had five speakers but our five included me and my wife and my daughter which meant we only had two speakers and I knew as soon as the first speaker opened his mouth that I was done and I could feel everyone behind me getting as embarrassed as me because it was so terrible all the things they were saying about me and even worse than the prosecutor and I knew it wouldn’t matter what any of my friends or my lawyer or me said because there was no breath in the room and only heavy mist and anger and even when the judge took forty five minutes to deliberate I knew he wasn’t deliberating because there was nothing to deliberate but only to calculate when he finally asked me to rise and my legs trembling and the number coming out of his mouth kind of garbled so it could have been something not so bad but I knew it was bad before my lawyer wrote it on a pad in front of him because I heard my daughter sobbing as soon as he uttered the first syllable and so I knew I was going away and I would never come back, not by myself anyway and then I turned around and everyone was stunned not knowing what to do and what had happened even though everyone knew what happened but you just keep telling yourself that it didn’t happen, nothing happened but of course it did, just that no one wanted to come near me and even my enemies were afraid to look at me because they knew it was somewhere and someplace they never thought they’d be anymore than me and you realize what an ugly place the courtroom is even for the judge and the bailiffs and the lawyers and the prosecutors and the security guys in the lobby and probably the guys who clean up after as it’s just a terrible place where nothing that goes on there makes anyone feel good but only dirty somehow as I could feel the heavy air suffocating everyone and even the enemies all just wanting to get out of that room where all the bad things in life come to their deliverance because all the bad things are part of everyone in that room and at the end of the day as every one was walking out everyone felt bad for themselves and no one was off the hook. Not even the Judge.
Up Next on White Collar Journal:
Wednesday (Justice Notes): Criminal Justice Reform
Thursday (Notes from Exisle): Log/Verse: Daily, fragmented reflections
Sunday (Prison Camp): More Stories from prison
If you’re new to White-Collar Journal, you can read earlier chapters and essays on incarceration, justice, and reentry at whitecollarjournal.com.
Thank you for reading White-Collar Journal. Subscribing is free, and I hope you’ll continue with me as I explore stories of incarceration, justice, and redemption.
If this piece resonated with you, consider sharing it or leaving a comment. To support this work and help spread awareness about justice reform for white-collar defendants, subscribe to White-Collar Journal and stay connected. John DiMenna is a member of the White Collar Support Group.
To leave a comment, Substack may ask you to verify your email address (a one-time step to prevent spam). You don’t need to subscribe or create an account. Just check your inbox for a one-time link.

